Catherine Creek md. 1) Andrew Sandusky on 4 June 1790 in Bourbon County, KY; 2) John Miller on 4 Feb 1801 in Warren County, KY; 3) TAYLOR, unknown; and 4) William Basket on 15 March 1846 in Franklin County, IL.(NOTE: This 4th marriage is "Catherine Taylor" to "William Basket.")
I have checked both Indiana and Illinois statewide marriages for a Catherine Miller to TAYLOR marriage--none found.
By the way, I doubt that Catherine had a child, Isaac Basket, from her husband Bailey Basket--she would have been 74 years old!!!