Tradition asserts that Emanuel lived to be 100 years old, dying in 1854, in Maryland, and that he married 2nd, Ann Miller,following Anna Maria's death. His death date and a second marriage are yet to be authenticated ...Milo Milo Custer wrote, following the publi-cation of his book CUSTER GENEALOGIES, that in light of the discovery of the Krebs and Fales land foreclosure he doubted the accuracy of his reference to the tradition that Emanuel lived to be 100 and that he married secondly, Ann Miller. He concluded that Emanuel died, perhaps in 1834 or 1833, and that he was married only to Anna Maria Fedele."
=========================================================== I have found definate pointers giving the second marriage as my family lineage. I have seen it once in Mormon records, and my great grandfather's brothers line have given my great great grandfather as uncle to General Custer. If my findings are pointing to accuracy of this line, John Custer was a half brother of Joseph Custer. Joseph was living at Burghill 1826.
A native of Frederick Co., MD. 1810 - 5th District - Allegheny Co. - MD - west of Evitt Creek; John is a son of Emanuel. Joseph, son of Anne Miller. Pointers in Trumbull county 1816-1826 show John, Charlotte, , Charlotte Custer Cummings Lived in Bristol Twp., Trumbull Co., OH. a grandson of Mary Cummings, the Cummings family are pointing there also.
Joseph Cummings, Sr. m. Polly [Mary] Custer 03 October 1810. Frederick Co., MD. Their son was also in Trumbull Co. "Marriage Licenses - Frederick Co., Md. - 1778-1810", 3 Oct 1810, Custer, Polly to Cimmings, Joseph.
I am looking for solid documentation of Emanuel Custer, 1754-c1854, and the second marriage to Anne Miller. Also descendants of this line. Charlotte was b. 04 March 1798, Elk Lick Twp., Allegheny Co., PA. St. John's Parish Register -Elk Lick Twp. - Somerset Co. - PA, May 13, 1789 to Nov. 4, 1801, St. John's Parish Register, Elk Lick Township
CUSTER Emanuel & Mary Fedele Charlotte, b. 4 Mar. 1798, Elk Lick Twp., Somerset Co. - PA. Mary Fedele d. 15 October 1799. Alleghany Co., MD Charlotte Custer m. Robert Cummins. Brookfield Township was formed in 1816. 1. "Custer Genealogies" Milo Custer - 1944, Pg. 64, First wife. Came early to Bristol & Austintown Twps. with brothers and sisters? (Note for brother, Thomas Cummins)
So far I can find no evidence of Joseph Custer's parents. Somewhere there must be solid information after death of Mary Fedele. d. 15 October 1799. Alleghany Co., MD
Need solid evidence of death of Mary Fedele. d. 15 October 1799. Charlotte was b. 04 March 1798. Mary Fedele. d. 15 October 1799. Alleghany Co., MD. [What church record might this be?] Cemetery Record?
1800 Federal Census, and birth of Joseph Custer. b. c1800. 1810 Federal Census, and two children, Charlotte  & Joseph [c1800]