Thank you all for the info in your posts on the Doty family. I am researching the Pride family (Susanna of Samuel Pride and Catherine Pride) and was following the Doty connection via her husband John.
I have a question about one of their children, Mary Catherine.
I believe that Mary Catherine Doty married Fred Kimple in 1885 (which is probably the record you are referring to). Mary Catherine was age 15 at that time. I later find Fred marrying again in 1889 to Mary Belle Potts. Fred is buried in Mt. Rose Cemetery (Moundsville) with the wife's name on the headstone listed as "Belle".
I then find a Mary Catherine Doty (same birth year) marrying Joseph Clifford Tomlinson in 1890. Joseph is the great-great-grandson of the "famed" pioneer and original settler of Moundsville, Joseph Tomlinson, Jr. (also buried at Mt. Rose).
Since I can't seem to find another Mary Catherine Doty born in the same time period in or around Marshall County, I am thinking that she married twice, the first being to Kimple and the second being to Tomlinson.
Curious what your or anyone else's thoughts/research is on Mary Catherine Doty.