On the Death certificate, Im not sure where the name "Caga" came from.I honestly don't think her husband (William Elmer) knew her fathers name.
William Elmer McFarland and Kate Doty were married in Meigs County Ohio, June 8, 1893.I have not seen the record, only found it in a book at the library.
Her obituary lists her name as Catherine Belle no family members other than husband and children are listed as survivors.
Several of her childrens birth certificates list her place of birth.She had 8 children (2 stillborn).Her first child's birth certificate lists her place of birth as Powhateu, OHIO.There is a Powhatan Point OH, in Belmont County Ohio, and is in the same district as the 1880 census where Ezekiel Doty is.
My next agenda is to try to find the obituary's of the other children of Ezekiel Doty to see if they list Catherine Doty and maybe a better clue as to if this Catherine is actually his daughter.
Maybe between the two of us (and hopefully others help) we can solve this mystery.