Re: Theodore Daugherty born 1809
Are you aware that there are a couple of Daughertys' buried in Smith Cemetery (now, Burnside) in Plain Twp., Franklin Co.,Oh ? Source- "Franklin County Ohio Cemetery Inscriptions in the United States Military District", copied by Clara C. Mark, Westerville, Ohio, Nov. 7, 1949; p. 2- John Daugherty who died Aug the 18, 1832, aged 49 (?) years, 6 mo & 21days (Inscription weathered).
Charlotte, wife of E.?, J.? Daugherty, died Jan 7, 1856, age 72 yrs.
I thought perhaps if this was a couple they might be Charlotte, (the daughter of Abraham Strait & Charlotte Comer) who married John Daugherty, s/o Anthony.
Hope this helps.