1860 census of Erie, PA Springfield Twp shows 4 men with surname Eagley. (brothers?)John, Abraham, Daniel and Jos.
Abraham Eagley born 1809 PAage 51 Christine (b) OHcan't tell if age is 52 or 32??? Henry, 14, born PA;Catharine 12, PA;Eunice 10, PA;Casper 6, PA; George, Millard and Frank .
Marriage cert. for Henry and Mary shows the following: Henry C. Eagley born 1845 in Erie, PA age 39. Mary L. Clark born Algansee, Michigan. Married 12 Nov 1884 in Grand Rapids.
1900 census of Osceola Mich. Sherman Twp shows Mary Clark born in Indiana. (your guess is as good as mine!) In household with Henry and Mary are daughters Carrie E born April 1885,Florence P born Nov 1889 and Amy born Dec 1894.