Sandi, You said this Charles William married Effie Bishop. I have been in touch with the Charles W. whose father, Charles W., Sr., married Effie Bishop 19 Feb 1907. This Charles W. was born 06 Oct 1880. I was also told that there was another Charles W. but, he was not related to this father and son. Now, besides Bishop, he remarried Rebecca P Gaunce, mother of THIS Charles W.( who was born 1924). I think it is worth another look for the spouse of the Charles W born 1846. I do not have a spouse for that one.