The mystery deepens! Andrew Gonser was in Noble Co. IN re census records. His 2nd wife was Eliza Lauer who he married in Coshocton Co. OH. They did have a daughter Mary b. c. 1856. Other daughters were Lydia, Sarah, Lovina. Andrew was still alive in 1900.
George Gonser died 1865 in Holmes Co. OH. His wife was Sarah Lower who died 1862. He married Rebecca Hummell as his 2nd wife. He had a daughter Mary b. c. 1849 (11 on 1860 OH census)and a daughter Eliza born 1853. I have George's will and probate records from Holmes Co. OH. No information that any of this family went to Indiana but records are not complete.