After searching for 15 yrs, I found it.Mary E COLE born Sep 1837 in Colebrook, Ashtabula co, OH, daughter of Gilbert COLE and Sarah OWEN married in 1862 William S GOODELL born 7 May 1837 in Madison co, NY he died between 1910 and 1920 in Des Moines, Polk co, IA.Mary E (COLE) GOODELL was an82 yr old widow -per the 1920 census Des Moines, IA, living with her son Frank E GOODELL, his wife, Hattie and their 4 children. --------------- The following is from: "History of Mills County, Iowa," Indian Creek Township [State Historical Company, Des Moines, 1881], pp 711-712. "GOODELL, WILLIAM S. merchant, Emerson P. O.; was born May 7, 1837, in Madison county, New York. At an early age he moved with his parents to Wyoming county, New York, where he remained until January 1862. The foundation of his education was laid in the common schools of the Empire State, and finished at Lima, New York. In 1863, he went to Ashtabula county, Ohio, and remained until 1865, being engaged in farming. He then moved to Whiteside county, Illinois, remaining until 1872, when he came to Emerson. He engaged in the stock and grain trade and in general merchandising until 1874, when the firm with which he had been connected as a member divided, and Mr. Goodell assumed the merchandising portion. He was married to Miss Mary E. daughter of Gilbert Cole, January 1, 1862, and to them have been born two sons, Frank E. and Fred R. Mr. Goodell and lady are both members of the Baptist church, of which Mr. G. is also a prominent official member. He is a large property holder, owning the Commercial hotel, and three residences, besides his fine residence and business block, and a farm of some 120 acres. the Goodell & Schaul elevator was built while the firm of that name was in existence. It is not necessary to say more of Mr. G., his business record is a history and a prophecy in itself."