Peter did have a brother Moses who was born around 1792. Moses' wife was Priscilla(~1794). Among their children were Louisa (~1820, Ohio)and Isabel (~1835, Kentucky). Peter had a son named Moses who was born in Ohio in 1820. He died in Grapevine Texas- Oct 1897. He was married to Nancy T. Beale (~1829, Kentucky) in November of 1846 in Missouri. They had two daughters as of the 1850 census (Abilla?(2) and LucyAnn(5/12). In the 1870 census in Randolph County, MO: S. J. Goodfellow (37) Born Virginia Sarah (37) wife James L. (16) Peter A. (8) Anna (7) Olive (3) Anna (76) the widow of Peter from NY (Peter died in 1869 in Randolph County. I assume that S. J. was the son of Peter and Anna since she is living with his family and Peter had just passed. Perhaps the other postings can clear that up.