Daniel W. Hinkley/Hinkly/Hinckley NY to OH

Daniel W. Hinkley/Hinckley/Hinkly born abt 1812
NY but then it gets very interesting. Married
1844 Summit Co OH or so we think as son Robert
Arteman born 1845 Summit Co OH. Tells that Daniel
is 21 (birth year 1823). But then gets even more
interesting 1850 census of Boston Summit Co OH
tells he is 38 (birth year 1812), then the 1860
census of Elyria Lorain Co OH says he is 57 living with a family name of Peck also census
taker assumed they were all the same surname of
Peck (birth year 1803).
Who was my Daniel W. Hinkley/Hinkly/Hinckley
father of my Anna Mae married 1st Henry Root,
m/2 Jesse Evans Humphreys. Daughter Pearl Narcissa Humphreys married Glen Day Gorball my
mothers' paternal grandfather.
Can anyone tell me about this man who was said
to have married an Eliza Jane Brannon.