Hi, I just saw this and I recently started research on this family. Specifically their older daughter Elizabeth W. Knowles Huston Waters Luckey (b.1848 Providence,R.I.) She was the third and final wife of my GGGrandfather Abner W. Waters. Elizabeth has an older brother ,Franklin,and then the three brothers born in California(William,Edward, and Ansel) She had five children by her first husband. Please contact me and I will gladly share my finding.