Lois, Thanks for your response>>>>> I post the following letter from my uncle James E. Manahan
The info on Dennis is mostly correct, but he didn't marry Ellen Talada until after 1860, because he was listed on 1860 census as married to Mary ? and several children. Also, I think the Dorothy Manahan listed on 1870 census with him was not his child. According to Shaffer Genealogy her father was George Fisher raised by the Manahans.
I (James) have death certificate for Ida May and it lists Larrabee as her father, but I think she may have been raised by the Larrabees as Ellen died about 6 wks after she (Ida May) was born and Larrabees lived close.