Gabriel and Eliz. McCool-VA, OH, IN

I am looking for Gabriel and Elizabeth (Goodrich) McCool. Both born in VA. Gabriel is said to be one of the early settlers of Highland Co.,Ohio. They moved to Washington Twp. Hamilton Co., IN abt 1852. Members of the Methodist Episcopal Church. Politically was a Whig. Emigrated from the Emerald Isle. Second daughter, Eliza (b. 12/25/1835/36 in Ohio) married Jonathan Carey in Hamilton co. IN 3/11/1854. I once thought they be in the Miami Co. Ohio McCools, but now I am not so sure. Any help will be appreciated.