James, I only have 3 Johns born in a time frame that fits your marriage data; 2 of them I know married someone else, and the 3rd was a soldier for whom I have no marriage, and who died in 1761. So unless one of the married twice, I can't help you. But I'll add the data to my "bits and pieces" file for future reference. Never know when something will turn up down the road. Do you have ANY additional data of this guy?