I am also a direct descendant of John & Nellie Oxford Winebarger. I am the grand-daughter of Virginia June Winebarger(married to Gilbert Folston), daughter of Hiram Roby Winebarger(married to Sally Graybeal). Hiram Roby was the son of Hiram Winebarger and Sarah Norris. Hiram was the son of John & Nellie. I have a few names and dates associated with this family, but not much. I don't know of any of John & Nellie's other children.I did, however, hear the same story about John Festler. I would love to exchange info. with you and anyone else interested.