Hi Maynard, Robert McNiel did a nice job on the report.I do have a couple of questions.
Robert mentions William Kennett McNiel, son of Daniel McNiel as marrying his cousin Nancy McNiel, daughter of Jacob McNiel, JR.But in the section on Jacob McNiel, JR, there is no mention of a daughter named "Nancy"?
Also, Robert shows Rebecca McNiel, daughter of Jacob McNiel and Annie Stevenson as marrying her cousin - John McNeill.In a book, I found at a public library, called "Giles County Marriages - 1806-1850 (Author VOGT) it states:
26 July 1835 - Rebecca McNeal & William Kinnison, PERM-Charles Kinnison, wit-Johnathan Bradley & John H. Bane, b-27 July 1835 by Johnathan Bradley
Was Rebecca McNiel married twice? Or is this a different Rebecca?
------------------- (Other marriages listed in the book "Giles County Marriages - 1806-1850):
13 August 1819 - Charles Miller & Ann McNeil - STATEMENT: "This is to satisfy the clark (clerk) that I am fully agreed to marry Charles Miller" signed by Ann McNeel (Charles Kennison is guardian for Ann); b-14 August 1819; wit- Daniel Hoge)
6 September 1823 - Joseph Pauley & Susanna McNeel; b-Charles Miller (NOTE: Susanna states that she is 27 years old); wit - Daniel Hoge
25 November 1839 - John Fanning & Malvina McNeel; b-Charles Miller; min-David Byrnes (NOTE: I also have John Fanning (widowed) & Elizabeth Pauley (daughter of Joseph and Susanna McNeil Pauley; marrying 3 March 1859 in Tazewell County, Virginia.)
29 Mar 1847 - William Hobson (Hoback) & Milly (Emily?) McNeely; Permission-Peter Hoback; bond-Charles Miller
From "Giles County, Virginia History" - Volume 1 by Research Committee Giles County, Historical Society - page 118 - under "Marriages"
5 Sept 1865 - James Bogle & Ann M. Pauley; L.J. Miller (could be Lorenzo Miller?); James - age 48 (widowed), born in Giles County, VA - lives in Bland; son of Ralph & Margret Bogle;Ann - age 33 - single; born & lives in Giles County, Virginia; daughter of Joseph & Susan Pauley.
------------------------- Again - I can't say that Susanna Pauley, daughter of Joseph and Susannah (McNeil) Pauley ever married James Bogle, but it is possible.Susannah is listed as 24 in the 1850 census for Giles County, VA, which does not match the age of either of the Susan's you mentioned in the 1860 census, so I don't know that I could say the marriage was true.More evidence needs to be found.