Re: William Rolfe 1787-1886
Here's a William S. Rollf married to a Christiana T. Darr in 1835 in Hamilton, Butler County, Ohio. I just happened to notice their marriage on the left side of the page. (My interest was in Zerah Rolfe's marriage to Sarah Currier on the right side of the page.) https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/XZDC-N61
This William S. Rollf is in Darr, Butler County, Ohio, in the 1840 census, but I have been unable to find him in later records.
Given that your William S. Rollf was relatively older when he married Laverna Hall I am wondering if the one I found could be a first marriage for him, especially since your William S. Rollf has a daughter Christiana.
FWIW, a common tradition is to name the first daughter after her paternal grandmother and the second daughter after her maternal grandmother. Which is perhaps why Christiana ended up third. :-)
If it weren't for the spelling of his surname, I would be trying to connect your William to the Rolfes I am studying.