Hi Shanna, this is Susan Gallagher. I have managed to lose you e-mail address, and the picture you sent me of the below land sale.
I did find a sale of land in Madison County, Indiana between Henry Wry (grantor) and John W. Renshaw ( granteed on 19 Mar 1840 for 40 acres. I haven't checked to see if it is the same land Henley bought in 1835. It sold for $305, and was the SE SE 1/4 of Section 36, Twp. 20, Range 7.