Re: The Pedigree of Capt. James Sands of Block Island
This still doesn't sound right or add up. There were certainly several Katherines in the family, but I haven't found that Edward Hutchinson II (1607-1669) had a daughter named Katherine. Even if he did, the Katherine who married James Walker and was mother to Sarah (Sands) was born around 1605 in England. Thus she was two years older than Edward II.
John Hutchinson and Anne Marbury had a daughter named Katherine Hutchinson also, but she was born about 1630 and died in the Pelham massacre of 1643 at the age of 13. Not a good fit as well.
For now it would seem that we need to leave her parentage in question. It is very possible that she came from the same family, but via what branch we still do not seem to know.