Re: The Tingley's in MA
From what I can gather Frederick Tingley married Effie Small 1897 in South Framingham, MA.She was born in Orleans, MA of Charles and Ruth.
I do find Roger Edward Tingley born 1900 in Boston but can not find a birth for his brother.
The family was living in Lynn,MA in the 1920 Census where Fred was a Clergyman.
I don't know anything about the children and their offspring but if I come across something I'll let you know.