Re: IR > NY > IL Tully's
James, it does sound like we have a match.I suspect Catherinemust have been related.There are too may common names from my tree, dates and locations that you have cited.
I don't have any information on a Catherine though.She wasn't listed in the probate records of Patrick Tully who could have been her father.
Have you pulled death records or church records on her and your John McLaughlin yet? That may help.Especially since they are buried in what is predominantly a family cemetery (while not named as such, most in that Deerfield cemetery in Illinois are Yore family related that I have found to date).
There is McLaughlin in the tree. Also, if she passed away prior to Patrick's death that would explain her not mentioned in the probate.