Re: Tuttles of Jefferson Co., NY
I think you are referring to Earl Alexander Tuthill/Tuttle, 20 Jul 1838, Dale, Wyoming, New York; died 31 Dec 1922, Attica, New York. According to Alva Tuttle's "TUTTLE TUTHILL LINES in AMERICA", he was the son of Samuel Denn Tuthill/Tuttle, born 24 Oct 1805, Goshen, New York; died 16 Feb 1880, Warsaw, New York and Charlotte Albright [22 May 1815, Ft. Hill, New York - 11 May 1889, Warsaw, New York].
It appears that Henderson Tuttle, recorded in Alva Tuttle's record, is indeed the Henry Tuttle, born 20 Feb 1816, son of Theodore Tuttle, 24 Dec 1793, Brattleboro, Vermont. Alva does not make the connection between the two.