Hi JoAnn, This is a confusing one, Wise County Va. Marriage Register 1856-1886 abstracted by John Mullins
Clevenger James, 21, S, Pi. Co.Ky., Res. Wise County, VA. on 1 Jan 1857 ?to Polly Vanover 21, S, Ashe County, NC, Res. Wise Co. VA. son of Jas. Mullins and E. Clevenger, daughter of Hiram Stamper and Catherine , occ. farmer . Min. J.W. Hill ( Reg. says daughter of P. Elder bond says daughter of Catherine) Bond.