Two Lines of Wendell's in New York

I have been for years trying to figure out if I have two actual lines of the Wendell family in New York.The two lines would be the Evert Wendell line and then there is the Wendell line that came to New Amsterdam, went to Shrewbury, New Jersey, then some of them migrated north.

Catalyna Van Dyke seems to be the stumbling stone on this.In the Evert Wendell line I find that she married Isaac Wendell, but in the Johannes/Jacob Wendell line she married Jacob Wendell.Could the Isaac Wendell have been a Jacob Isaac Wendell?

I have gone around and around on this for more years that most people can count.

Does anyone have any insight on this?Thanks....